In a quiet corner of Amagansett, New York, a unique historical site remains waiting for its buyer – a windmill. It was here in the 1950s that Marilyn Monroe and playwright Arthur Miller hid from intrusive journalists. The opportunity to own this unusual piece of history is being offered for $12 million.

The two-story windmill with two bedrooms and one bathroom first appeared on the real estate market back in 2013, and has been listed for sale again since 2019. The price has hardly changed over the past decade, which, according to the real estate agent, is due to the owner’s patience.

Built in 1830, the windmill stands on a picturesque plot of land measuring 5.45 acres. The current price of $12 million is half a million dollars higher than the original. The owner is aware of the uniqueness of his property and is confident in its value. On such a plot, you can build a huge mansion. 5-acre plots in Amagansett are a great rarity, and considering inflation, according to the seller, the price is quite in line with the real value.

Some mechanical elements of the windmill have been preserved inside the three-story structure. The plot is not fenced, and wild animals move freely through its forest. With proper planning and thoughtful design, you can preserve the windmill and use it as a guest house or harmoniously fit it into the landscape of a new mansion without disturbing the overall picture. Unlike decorative windmills used in some architectural solutions, this is a real, authentic historical object.

The historic windmill in the Hamptons is still waiting for its new owner. Only time will tell whether it will become part of a luxurious mansion or remain a silent witness to history, continuing to turn its wings in the gentle breeze.