Jennifer Lopez’s divorce from Ben Affleck, finalized nearly five months after her August 2024 filing, has left fans buzzing about the fate of a particular item: her stunning engagement ring. The radiant green diamond ring, valued at over $5 million, was revealed in court documents to remain in Lopez’s possession. This exquisite 8.5-carat gemstone, flanked by two half-moon diamonds and set on a platinum band, carries a deeply personal engraving from Affleck: “not.going.anywhere.” For Lopez, who has often cited green as her lucky color, the ring holds special significance and a connection to happier times.

Despite its sentimental value, not all fans agree with Lopez’s decision to keep the ring. Some questioned the practicality and meaning behind holding onto such a memento from a marriage that ended. Comments ranged from curiosity about her motivations—”Why keep a reminder of failure?”—to outright criticism, with some fans labeling the ring a “consolation prize.” Others speculated that Affleck likely doesn’t want the ring back, given the circumstances of their split.

The debate over the ring also drew comparisons to Lopez’s past relationships. Fans noted that she reportedly retained the $1.8 million engagement ring from her former fiancé, Alex Rodriguez, after their 2021 breakup. While some commenters expressed sympathy for Lopez, agreeing that it’s common not to return an engagement ring post-marriage, others called for the actress to let go of such items, accusing her of clinging to material possessions tied to past relationships.

Lopez’s decision to handle her divorce without legal representation has further highlighted her independence throughout this process. Known as filing “pro per,” this move allowed her to finalize the proceedings quickly and on her own terms. Notably, she waived spousal support for herself and requested the same for Affleck. Their lack of a prenuptial agreement added another layer of complexity, meaning their nearly two years of marital earnings were divided as community property.

With the legal proceedings behind her, Lopez appears to be moving forward. While fans remain divided over her choice to keep the ring, the singer and actress has cleared the path for a fresh start. Whether seen as a symbol of resilience or a contentious keepsake, the green diamond ring will forever serve as a reminder of a significant chapter in her life.