Hugh Jackman and Sutton Foster recently fueled speculation after a casual date night sparked online chatter. The pair, who starred together in The Music Man, were seen enjoying each other’s company at an In-N-Out drive-thru in Los Angeles on January 12, 2025. Fans couldn’t help but notice the Broadway star’s relaxed outfit—an oversized shirt paired with sweatpants—which led many to wonder if Foster might be expecting. Comments flooded social media, with users speculating, “Is she pregnant?” while others confidently declared, “She looks pregnant.”

The 56-year-old actor and his 49-year-old girlfriend appeared smitten as they shared affectionate moments, exchanging kisses in the drive-thru line and outside their car. Jackman’s khaki outfit and Foster’s laid-back style reflected the relaxed vibe of their outing. However, not all attention was positive, as some fans questioned Foster’s appearance and even drew comparisons to Jackman’s ex-wife, Deborra-Lee Furness. Critics remarked on her fashion choices, while others defended the couple’s happiness, emphasizing that their joy is all that truly matters.

This new relationship comes on the heels of Jackman’s split from Furness in September 2023, ending their 27-year marriage. The exes, who share two adopted children, Oscar and Ava, had openly discussed their struggles with infertility and the emotional journey that led them to adopt. Meanwhile, Foster, also a parent through adoption, has a daughter, Emily Dale, whom she welcomed in 2017 with her ex-husband, Ted Griffin. Both Jackman and Foster share a deep bond over their experiences with adoption, which has further strengthened their connection.

Insiders suggest Jackman and Foster’s relationship developed during their time performing in The Music Man, sparking rumors of an affair while they were still married to their respective ex-spouses. Despite the controversy surrounding the beginning of their romance, fans are rallying behind the couple, with many pointing out their shared love for theater and their evident happiness together. Some even noted their striking resemblance, humorously referring to them as “twins.”

As the couple navigates their newfound relationship, they’ve been spotted enjoying various outings, including Jackman’s attendance at Foster’s Broadway performances. Fans and theatergoers alike have praised their chemistry, both on and off the stage, with Jackman previously lauding Foster as an exceptional talent and friend. Despite the scrutiny, the couple seems to be focusing on their happiness, leaving fans to celebrate their love and eagerly speculate about the possibility of a new addition to their lives.